There are so many things to get used to being back in Germany, in Europe, in the 'first world.' Small things like when I leave a room I don't have to stow away all electronics to prevent the roof from leaking on them when it rains. Big things like CLEAN WATER OMG. Clothes that get clean, body that gets clean! Food that doesn't make you sick in the least. Variety in food! We haven't been to a supermarket yet, but I know it will be a shock. What I have learned most is the value of working sewage and water treatment systems. This is everything for quality of life. Without them, you have so much unnecessary illness, dirt and smells. I keep telling Toni, I would eat off every surface in Germany everything looks so dang CLEAN.
The thing is, Addis Ababa is not really Ethiopia. Whenever we'd go out to the provinces, to where 85% of the population lives, we'd realize how removed Addis is - how Europeanized and fancy in so many ways. Finding a working toilet is a challenge in Addis, but they do exist. Life there is luxurious - just ask dear Zemzem, the young Guraghe woman who we shared a house with. She supports her whole family (mother + 5 siblings) on her $40/month salary - they still live out in Soddo, in a thatched tukul/cottage, farming teff and barley. For us, the house in Addis came with new challenges - barricading every nook and cranny to prevent full rat invasion, "leaky" roofing, bad plumbing, daily power outages. For Zemzem, this house was incredibly luxe.
Where we grow up so determines what we consider proper living standards, but I know that everyone here in Germany - with their amazing infrastructure and clean streets - is not much happier than people in Ethiopia, despite a much lower physical standard of living. This is a fallacy of much charitable/development thinking, that everyone in physical poverty is also emotionally impoverished. No in fact, that's another thing to get used to being away from Ethiopia - the lack of community in the sense that everyone is constantly greeting each other, asking if they can help each other - there is an amazing camaraderie that "developed" countries have in some sense abandoned. So many people now live alone, shuttling themselves between places in cars, so this constant interaction you get in African countries, with 12 people to one home, crowded public transport and lots of walking, is very much missing.
The point is. I read this really good op-ed in the New York Times, written by Warren Buffet's son. It's a very honest critique of the charitable industry that does more to pump up the egos of donors than actually improve peoples' lives. I can attest to this a million times over, seeing how organizations work on the ground in the countries I've been working in the last years. I think the issue lies in this critical misunderstanding of people living in physical poverty. They've been simplified and blanketed to be these pathetic, unintelligent creatures who are happy for just any hand-out, but have no self determination, capacity, or even desire to improve their own lives. Let me tell you, people are people everywhere (duh) - sure, Ethiopians are not miserable, they are strong and quite happy people, but every family I met with told me how much they'd love to get rid of the open sewage running outside their doors. They want to be able to pay for healthcare, and not just stay at home and languish in pain from disease because they don't have the $10 or $30 for treatment. These are real problems they are frustrated with, that they themselves acknowledge. Would you like someone to come in and tell you what needs fixing in your own life? Don't you know what challenges you face more than anyone? But no, these are just "people in need," and "we" know what's best for them.
What's needed (like the article says) is systematic change. It's governments stepping up and taking control of the social contract they're meant to have with their people. It's the end of pandering to people in power, but listening instead to those "at the bottom." (Remember the "first shall be last and the last shall be first?" My favourite.) It's for all the ridiculous humanitarian organizations and donor representatives to stop sending "experts" over to a country for a 2 week stint where they stay in a 5-star hotel and visit a school and take pictures with the kids and say the have "been to Africa." No you have not. There is no incentive to change the systemic challenges of physical poverty because those in charge - those who are responsible for making the decisions - are themselves so far removed from the reality of food insecure, rural African livelihoods. They make demands of people in these situations that make no sense, all in the guise of "development." (This is a big part of my PhD thesis, I am still doing that after all. :)
No one wants to actually live in physically poor situations - the USAID office in Addis? Everyone who works there gets a mansion with a generator and back-up water supply. They are allowed an initial 2,000 pounds of food shipped into the country from the US so they don't have to deal with the limited Ethiopian fare. They get direct shipments from Amazon.com while in Ethiopia to further ensure they don't "miss" anything. And these are the people making decisions for developing rural Ethiopia? How can they possibly understand what life there is actually like? A couple "field visits" doesn't cut it. You have to LIVE there. You have to live the reality of no running water and a thatched cottage home and walking 40 km to a health station with no staff as your only recourse for treatment.
There is much that is wrong in the world - but not in the way it's traditionally depicted. And while we have an obscene level of privilege, given the infrastructure we are blessed with for no other reason than we were lucky enough to be born in a first world country, we are not more privileged in emotional or intellectual capacity, and should never ever think we can determine others' happiness by our own measures.
You can tell I'm still reeling from all we've experienced and seen. I will be for months and years, just as I still haven't fully "processed" Mozambique, Niger, or Brazil. Besides, my engagement with these worlds is never ended - I'm back in Zambia in less than 3 weeks, then the Congo in September. I wouldn't feel myself if I wasn't constantly engaged with this. I'd miss it all too much.
But for now. For the next 2 weeks, it's time to do very little except re-acquaint ourselves with milk and cereal, bread and cheese - chat with Toni's family, take bike rides, WALK BAREFOOT mmmmm. It's so so so deliciously lovely here I could burst. We're so happy. I think I could easily say I am happier today than at any point in my life. Toni is a dream husband, we did it all together, and I'm so grateful for that. Life is good, y'all. Life is good.
The thing is, Addis Ababa is not really Ethiopia. Whenever we'd go out to the provinces, to where 85% of the population lives, we'd realize how removed Addis is - how Europeanized and fancy in so many ways. Finding a working toilet is a challenge in Addis, but they do exist. Life there is luxurious - just ask dear Zemzem, the young Guraghe woman who we shared a house with. She supports her whole family (mother + 5 siblings) on her $40/month salary - they still live out in Soddo, in a thatched tukul/cottage, farming teff and barley. For us, the house in Addis came with new challenges - barricading every nook and cranny to prevent full rat invasion, "leaky" roofing, bad plumbing, daily power outages. For Zemzem, this house was incredibly luxe.
Where we grow up so determines what we consider proper living standards, but I know that everyone here in Germany - with their amazing infrastructure and clean streets - is not much happier than people in Ethiopia, despite a much lower physical standard of living. This is a fallacy of much charitable/development thinking, that everyone in physical poverty is also emotionally impoverished. No in fact, that's another thing to get used to being away from Ethiopia - the lack of community in the sense that everyone is constantly greeting each other, asking if they can help each other - there is an amazing camaraderie that "developed" countries have in some sense abandoned. So many people now live alone, shuttling themselves between places in cars, so this constant interaction you get in African countries, with 12 people to one home, crowded public transport and lots of walking, is very much missing.
The point is. I read this really good op-ed in the New York Times, written by Warren Buffet's son. It's a very honest critique of the charitable industry that does more to pump up the egos of donors than actually improve peoples' lives. I can attest to this a million times over, seeing how organizations work on the ground in the countries I've been working in the last years. I think the issue lies in this critical misunderstanding of people living in physical poverty. They've been simplified and blanketed to be these pathetic, unintelligent creatures who are happy for just any hand-out, but have no self determination, capacity, or even desire to improve their own lives. Let me tell you, people are people everywhere (duh) - sure, Ethiopians are not miserable, they are strong and quite happy people, but every family I met with told me how much they'd love to get rid of the open sewage running outside their doors. They want to be able to pay for healthcare, and not just stay at home and languish in pain from disease because they don't have the $10 or $30 for treatment. These are real problems they are frustrated with, that they themselves acknowledge. Would you like someone to come in and tell you what needs fixing in your own life? Don't you know what challenges you face more than anyone? But no, these are just "people in need," and "we" know what's best for them.
What's needed (like the article says) is systematic change. It's governments stepping up and taking control of the social contract they're meant to have with their people. It's the end of pandering to people in power, but listening instead to those "at the bottom." (Remember the "first shall be last and the last shall be first?" My favourite.) It's for all the ridiculous humanitarian organizations and donor representatives to stop sending "experts" over to a country for a 2 week stint where they stay in a 5-star hotel and visit a school and take pictures with the kids and say the have "been to Africa." No you have not. There is no incentive to change the systemic challenges of physical poverty because those in charge - those who are responsible for making the decisions - are themselves so far removed from the reality of food insecure, rural African livelihoods. They make demands of people in these situations that make no sense, all in the guise of "development." (This is a big part of my PhD thesis, I am still doing that after all. :)
No one wants to actually live in physically poor situations - the USAID office in Addis? Everyone who works there gets a mansion with a generator and back-up water supply. They are allowed an initial 2,000 pounds of food shipped into the country from the US so they don't have to deal with the limited Ethiopian fare. They get direct shipments from Amazon.com while in Ethiopia to further ensure they don't "miss" anything. And these are the people making decisions for developing rural Ethiopia? How can they possibly understand what life there is actually like? A couple "field visits" doesn't cut it. You have to LIVE there. You have to live the reality of no running water and a thatched cottage home and walking 40 km to a health station with no staff as your only recourse for treatment.
There is much that is wrong in the world - but not in the way it's traditionally depicted. And while we have an obscene level of privilege, given the infrastructure we are blessed with for no other reason than we were lucky enough to be born in a first world country, we are not more privileged in emotional or intellectual capacity, and should never ever think we can determine others' happiness by our own measures.
You can tell I'm still reeling from all we've experienced and seen. I will be for months and years, just as I still haven't fully "processed" Mozambique, Niger, or Brazil. Besides, my engagement with these worlds is never ended - I'm back in Zambia in less than 3 weeks, then the Congo in September. I wouldn't feel myself if I wasn't constantly engaged with this. I'd miss it all too much.
But for now. For the next 2 weeks, it's time to do very little except re-acquaint ourselves with milk and cereal, bread and cheese - chat with Toni's family, take bike rides, WALK BAREFOOT mmmmm. It's so so so deliciously lovely here I could burst. We're so happy. I think I could easily say I am happier today than at any point in my life. Toni is a dream husband, we did it all together, and I'm so grateful for that. Life is good, y'all. Life is good.












